Skip to the content
LaunchedHere
Sign in Launchyours

Fair Play in Launch Voting, and Why the Rules Exist

Rules · 8 min read ·

Why launch competitions ban vote buying, fake accounts and direct upvote requests, what counts as manipulation, and how fair results protect founders.

Illustration: Cartoon referee with a whistle, big sticker badge reading fair play in rounded type, bright accent colour

Every game needs rules, and a launch competition is a game in the friendliest sense: a bit of fun with real stakes. The rules about votes are not there to spoil anybody's enjoyment. They exist because a ranking is only worth having if people believe it. This article explains the main rules, the reasoning behind them and how to enjoy the competition without going near the line.

The core idea: a vote should mean something

A vote is a tiny statement: "I looked at this and I liked it." If you can buy votes, create fake ones or pressure people into giving them, the statement becomes false. And a ranking made of false statements is worthless to everyone, including the people who cheated, because nobody trusts what they won.

That is the whole logic. Every specific rule is a way of protecting the meaning of a vote.

Rule one: do not ask directly for votes

Product Hunt's launch guide states that you cannot ask people directly to upvote your product, and it tells makers to ask people to visit and comment instead. Hacker News's guidelines are similarly clear: do not solicit upvotes, comments or submissions, and vote and comment when you come across something you personally find interesting, not for promotion.

Why? Because a vote requested as a favour is a vote for a person, not for the product. It also gives well-connected founders an unfair edge over people with smaller networks.

What you can do instead is ask for attention and honesty. "Here is my launch; I would love your honest reaction" is fine. "Please vote for me" is not.

Rule two: no buying votes

Selling votes is a business. It is also a way to ruin a competition. On this site, votes can never be bought, and the structure of the platform reflects this: paid ranking, community votes, verification and factual data are separate systems, labelled as such. If you pay for a feature, you are paying for visibility in a labelled placement, not for any change in the community's votes.

Even outside our site, buying votes is a bad bet. Platforms look for patterns. Votes from fresh accounts, from clusters of the same network or at odd times can be removed, and the products involved can be penalised.

Rule three: no fake or duplicate accounts

One person, one account, one voice. Creating extra accounts to vote, comment or cheer is a form of manipulation, whatever the motive. Related to this, some platforms restrict who may launch. Product Hunt, for instance, says company accounts are prohibited and only personal accounts can launch products. Read the account rules of any platform before you enter, and follow them even if they seem fussy.

Rule four: no vote trading

"I will vote for you if you vote for me" feels harmless and friendly. It is also the seed of a voting ring. A circle of founders agreeing to boost each other produces results that reflect friendship, not interest. Hacker News's guidelines ask users not to solicit votes, which covers organised exchanges.

The healthy alternative is to look at other products out of genuine curiosity. If you like something, say so. If you are asked to do the same for you, politely decline the trade and offer feedback instead.

Rule five: be honest in what you say

Fair play is not only about votes. A launch page that claims "used by thousands" when it has been used by dozens, or "backed by experts" when it has not, misleads the community. Platforms may remove content that is deceptive, and readers have long memories.

Google's spam policies take a related view of manipulation: they describe practices intended to deceive and not to help people. Different context, same principle: honesty over tricks.

Rule six: respect other founders

Competitions bring rivals into the same space. Do not insult competitors, do not post fake negative comments and do not report entries without cause. If you see a real violation, use the platform's reporting tools and leave it to them.

How platforms spot cheating

Without giving a manual to cheaters, it is fair to say that platforms use a mix of automated checks and human review. They look for unusual patterns: bursts of votes from new accounts, many accounts sharing similar behaviour, votes that arrive without any browsing, or comments that look copied. They also rely on community reports.

When something looks wrong, the response may include removing the votes, removing the entry from the ranking, restricting accounts or banning repeat offenders. The details differ by platform, and they are usually not published in full.

What fair promotion looks like

You are allowed, and encouraged, to tell people about your launch. The line is in how.

Fine:

  • Posting your link on your own channels, with an invitation to look.
  • Emailing people who have asked to hear from you.
  • Sharing in communities where it is relevant and allowed, as part of normal participation.
  • Asking people to try the product and tell you what they think.
  • Thanking people who engage.

Not fine:

  • Messaging strangers en masse with "please vote".
  • Offering gifts or discounts in exchange for votes.
  • Organising a group to vote at the same moment.
  • Paying for votes or accounts.
  • Creating fake testimonials.

When you are unsure, ask yourself: "If every founder did this, would the ranking still mean something?" If not, do not do it.

Why fairness is good for you

It might seem that rule-following is a handicap, but over a longer period it works in your favour.

  • Trust. A fair result is one you can mention without embarrassment.
  • Better information. Honest votes and comments tell you what people actually think.
  • Better community. Founders who treat each other well help each other afterwards.
  • Less risk. You will never lose a badge or a page for something you did not do.
  • A clear conscience, which is underrated.

What to do if you suspect cheating

If you think another entry has broken the rules, resist the urge to confront them in public. Gather what you can: links, times, patterns. Report it using the platform's tools. Then get back to your own launch. Accusations in comment threads rarely help and sometimes backfire.

If someone accuses you wrongly, respond calmly with facts and, if needed, contact the platform. An honest record of what you did and when, such as your launch log, is your best defence.

The difference between paid placement and votes

It is worth restating a point that causes confusion. Many platforms, including ours, offer paid options: a paid launch that picks its week, being featured or buying a bundle. These affect when and where you are shown. They do not change the community's votes. Keeping the two apart is how a platform can pay its bills and still run a fair competition.

On our site, paid options such as featured placement at $19 are priced by our team and are always labelled as paid. The community leaderboard remains separate.

Where to read the rules

The acceptable use page on this site sets out what you may and may not do on this site, including voting. It is worth five minutes before you enter. The leaderboard page shows results and the submit page starts your entry. The about-founders page names the people who answer for those rules.

Questions founders ask about the grey areas

"Is it all right to post my launch in a group chat?" Sharing a link with people who want to see it is normal. What makes it a problem is pressure: a message that says "everyone please vote now" turns sharing into organised voting. Share the link, say what you would like feedback on and leave the choice to each person.

"What about offering a free trial to people who comment?" An incentive tied to commenting or voting distorts what the comments mean. A free trial offered to everyone, on your own site, is a different matter, because it does not depend on what anyone does on the platform.

"My team members want to vote. Is that fine?" Teams are made of real people with real opinions, but a launch where the first dozen votes come from employees tells the audience little. Many founders ask team members to try the product and comment honestly, and let them decide about voting by the platform's rules.

"Someone offered to boost my launch for a fee." Decline. Whatever they promise, you are being sold manipulation, and you are the one who will bear the consequences if it is detected.

"What if I made a mistake?" If you realise you broke a rule, stop, tell the platform if appropriate and correct it. Honesty after an error is far better received than concealment.

A short pledge you can adopt

Many founders find it helpful to write their own rules in advance. Something like: "I will ask people to look and comment, never to vote. I will never pay for votes or accounts. I will reply honestly to every comment. I will describe any result accurately. I will help at least one other founder this week." Pin it above your desk. When you are tired at the end of a long launch day, a plain written commitment is a good thing to have in front of you.

The takeaway

Fair play is not about being nice for its own sake. It is about keeping a vote meaningful. Do not ask for votes, do not buy them, do not fake them and do not trade them. Invite attention, earn comments, answer honestly and let the result be whatever it is. A result earned that way is worth having, and a result earned any other way is not worth the risk.

Questions and answers

Why can't I ask for upvotes?
Product Hunt says you cannot ask people directly to upvote and should ask them to visit and comment instead. Hacker News tells users not to solicit upvotes, comments or submissions. Direct requests make votes less meaningful.
Can votes be bought on this site?
No. Votes can never be bought here. Paid placement, community voting and verification are separate systems and are labelled separately.
What counts as manipulation?
Buying votes, using fake or duplicate accounts, trading votes in secret groups, and coordinated pressure campaigns are all forms of manipulation.
What happens if someone breaks the rules?
Consequences depend on the platform and can include removal of votes, removal from the ranking or loss of an account. Check each platform's policy.

Sources

Support